in Search
Welcome to Neopoleon - Sign in | Join | Help
Navigation: Home | Forums | Galleries

Doctor Who, the BBC, the Rest of the World, and Bittorrent

I wonder how many people know that tonight is the season finale of the first run of Doctor Who that’s been on television since the last century.

You certainly wouldn’t have any reason to know it in the states. If you ever look at the listings for BBC America, it’s obvious that the People in Charge over there think that Americans want:

– Reruns of the bad episodes of the Avengers (those without Diana Rigg as Emma Peel)

– The same old episodes of Monty Python’s Flying Circus (a show we ‘mericans all pretend to understand, but really don’t – at all – period)

– Millions of Benny Hill reruns – around the clock – all day, every day

I don’t have any idea how they determined the lineup, but it’s awful. BBC America is like a dumping ground for the BBC archives.

Sure, I’m exaggerating the lameness of BBCA, but not by much. It’s a real stinker of a channel.

And to think they could have shown the first season of this new Doctor Who series, which just happens to be the best since Tom Baker hung his scarf up in his closet and walked off into obscurity. The stories are still lame as hell, but they’re offset by the higher quality characters and effects. Christopher Eccleston has kicked so much Doctor Who bootay that going back and watching the older episodes hurts (the Tom Baker years excepted).

And still, all we have over here is Benny Hill and a poorly co-starred Patrick McNee with huge lamb-chops erupting from beneath his bowler and taking over his face like a sort of intelligent hairy fungus.

People change. I’ve had some very harsh stances concerning file sharing programs like bittorrent, but with no other way to view the new Doctor Who series, and with the first episode intentionally leaked over bittorrent, I’ve had a hard time stopping myself from grabbing the shows as they’ve appeared. The temptation of hearing the slicing 30hz rasp of a metal box screaming “EXTERMINATE” has proven too much for me. I am a criminal.

It makes me wonder what television studios are thinking. The new Battlestar Galactica is a good example. Released first in the UK, the entire series was available via bittorrent before the third episode had played on ‘merican screens. I respect the desire to control distribution, but it’s pretty obvious now that the viewers have decided how they’d like to receive their broadcasts, and they’re voting with their file sharing clients.

I read a few interviews with the Man Behind the New Galactica, and his concern over file sharing systems like bittorrent was simply that there was no way to track viewers.

The answer to this seems so simple that I’m sure I’m missing something, but what the heck: Why not release a version of the show over bittorrent that:

– Contains commercials (they have to pay for this somehow)

– Contains several “nag” spots reminding people to go to a website where they could click a button that would increment a counter, making it possible to approximate the number of people who get the show over the net (I’d be willing to do this in exchange for the convenience)

– Is released a week after the show has already played so the stations airing the show don’t feel short-changed – also include a small spot at the beginning which says something to the effect of “If you had been watching this on [Station X] then you wouldn’t be a week behind”

Seems sane. Seems smart.

Back in the day, a studio could decide to release a show in the UK and not the states; a studio could release the show in multiple countries but with different play dates. Not now, though. There’s no point. If you tell us that a show is going to be released in the UK and then played in America three months later, the people with the means (and there are a lot of ‘em now) aren’t going to wait. There’s this whole high-speed worldwide network of publicly accessible machines to consider, you know?

Anyway, I’m looking forward to the last episode of the season, which is also the last episode starring Eccleston. His tenure as the Doctor was way too short. When it’s over, I suppose I’ll go back to watching what the execs think I want: old grainy reruns of Brits dressing up as women and holding potato sack races while singing songs about spam and other silliness.

Sigh.

Published Saturday, June 18, 2005 8:20 PM by Rory

Filed Under:

Comments

 

Paul Murphy said:

Completely agree. BBCA has so much potential if it were just Channel 4 unfiltered and they play crap.
June 18, 2005 9:22 PM
 

Steve Loughran said:

We could never bring ourselves to pay the premium to get BBC-in-exile while in the US. It was expensive drivel. Really, eastenders, benny hill, and that vicar-of-dibley junk. Where was league of gentleman, little britain, the modern subversive stuff?

However, much of it is drivel in the UK too. Celebrity Love island -'nuff said. its just they selectively pick the worst of the worst and send it to the US, to make, what Fox look sophisticated. Maybe that's why, there is some congress-backed dumping law requiring foreign tv companies not to make US-made TV look good, with a matching clause for record companies...
June 18, 2005 9:35 PM
 

Ian Smith said:

The new series cost a lot more money than the old series and one gets the impression that BBC America just decided they couldn't afford it (where Australia and New Zealand could - go figure!)

Tonight's last episode was a corker. I haven't thought much of Russel T Davies' episodes - those written by the guest writers have generally been much better - but he did a great job on the last episode. The daleks have NEVER looked so good!

If it's any compensation we have a similar situation in the UK with the US show "Lost". Channel 4 bought it at the same time as "Desperate Housewives" and what have they done with it? Decided to delay it for a year and bury it in the Summer schedule when nobody watches TV.

It's depressing to have endless cack reality TV shows on in peak slots while the classy fare like "Six Feet Under" and "West Wing" get shown at some God-forsaken hour and shunted around the schedule so that you can't possibly remember its time slot.
June 18, 2005 10:19 PM
 

Chris Lundie said:

Witness the fact that BBC Canada, a premium cable/satellite channel, is not showing the new Doctor Who series. But the CBC did show it (and leaked the first episode to the rest of the world). Thanks, tax payers!
June 18, 2005 11:00 PM
 

Brook said:

Tonights episode (watched it on BBC1 you pirating scum) had a bit of a deus ex ending about it and I was hoping for a return of Davros, but the series has been good and should get much better under David Tennant.

I haven't ever seen a full episode of Benny hill because his sexiest jokes aren't with "current viewer trends", but BBCA sounds a lot like UKGold that just shows reruns of Only Fools And Horses (Monty Python would be a nice change).

The BBC has a beta program running for streaming episodes of stuff over the net, so wearing an eyepatch won't be your only option forever (http://www.bbc.co.uk/imp/).
June 18, 2005 11:31 PM
 

Rory said:

Steve -

"However, much of it is drivel in the UK too."

But at least it's *new* drivel.

Like most normal people, I already own Black Adder, Fawlty Towers, and the rest, so tuning in to BBCA is useless.

An equivalent situation would be if Fox in the UK only broadcasted the Brady Bunch and the Partridge Family.

Ick.
June 18, 2005 11:37 PM
 

Rory said:

Ian -

"The new series cost a lot more money than the old series and one gets the impression that BBC America just decided they couldn't afford it (where Australia and New Zealand could - go figure!)"

That's so interesting. It reminds me of where I lived in Paris - a place called "la Fondation des Etats-Unis" which was part of a large collection of country-specific dormitories.

There were buildings from countries all over the world, most of them much poorer than the states.

Yet, who has the *worst* building on campus? Who has the building which was described by a popular travel guide as having the quality of "prison-like squalor"?

Yup - the states. All the money in the world, and nothing to show for it.

Crappy dorms and no Doctor Who. It's a shame.

"Tonight's last episode was a corker. I haven't thought much of Russel T Davies' episodes - those written by the guest writers have generally been much better - but he did a great job on the last episode. The daleks have NEVER looked so good!"

I thought the dalek in the episode called "Dalek" was great - as much as I enjoy watching the old fake-looking plastic held-together-by-school-glue daleks, the new ones are incredible. The glowing blue "eye" light makes a huge difference for such a subtle feature.

Haven't seen tonight's episode yet, but I'm pumped for it :)
June 18, 2005 11:42 PM
 

Rory said:

Brook -

"I was hoping for a return of Davros, but the series has been good and should get much better under David Tennant."

I would have been upset to have seen Davros since he was killed off in "Resurrection of the Daleks" (wasn't he?).

I haven't seen the episode yet, but I'm guessing that the leader is just going to be some variation of the Supreme Dalek, although I'd like it if y'alls just don't say anything yet - it's downloading now :)
June 18, 2005 11:47 PM
 

Rory said:

Brook -

"The BBC has a beta program running for streaming episodes of stuff over the net, so wearing an eyepatch won't be your only option forever"

Also wanted to say that I'm going to be buying the DVD set of these when it comes out (provided the BBC is smart enough to sell 'em here in the states - and hopefully along with the Doctor Who Confidentials).

While it doesn't make it "OK," I'm hoping to offset some of my badness by shelling out dough for the series when it's available. I'd like to see it continue, and that's not going to happen if it's just a bunch of freeloaders watching it.

I'll do my part...
June 18, 2005 11:49 PM
 

MattyT said:

Heya Rory,

Piracy can be good!

Check out these links on my blog that point to a talk given by Marc Pesce. It's long, but gold.

http://sublimesoftware.blogspot.com/2005/06/marc-pesce-piracy-is-good.html

Cheers,
Matt
June 19, 2005 12:41 AM
 

daniel said:

rory...you're not alone. i too am a criminal. I'm saddened by the fact that the only option for getting new episodes of the doctor is via torrents. the new show is awesome. i cant believe that eccleston is only doing one series. he's the perfect doctor. i do think they 'jumped the shark' a bit when the 'freelancing' con guy joined the crew. but thats o.k. Eccleston sells the show.
With Galactica, however, i still watched them on sci-fi as they were shown in the U.S. It's kinda silly that they were released at differing times. They'll never really know what the U.S. viewership was for the series, because so many americans downloaded the show and really felt no need to watch it on sci-fi. so the ratings may be low for the show, yet be very popular.
June 19, 2005 2:40 AM
 

Rory said:

daniel -

"i cant believe that eccleston is only doing one series."

ARRRGGHHH! I know. It stinks. I could do with another three or four seasons of the guy.

I can't blame him for leaving, though. From the interviews, it sounds like he was working 12-16 hour days for eight months straight. Aside from the workload, it would be *weird* to be spending the majority of your waking hours pretending to be somebody else, you know? That'd drive me crazy(-ier).

"he's the perfect doctor."

I didn't like him the first time I saw him on screen in the premier episode, but he grew on me, and now he's probably my favorite doctor ever (or at least tied with Tom Baker).

He has a real childlike way about him that makes his peformance as Mr. Important very charming.

I also like Rose. Not at first, but she grew on me, too. She can be a real ass-kicker when it matters.

"They'll never really know what the U.S. viewership was for the series, because so many americans downloaded the show"

Not entirely true. Since most of us don't have those set-top ratings boxes, downloading habits shouldn't have a large impact.

That said, viewership for the series *was* pretty low. I think it was something like 800,000 per episode, which is just... well, pretty small, eh?

Anyway, with the new series coming out in July (in the states first this time, so it'll be the Brits downloading), at least we know it was popular enough to warrant a continuation.

Which makes me a happy little bastard.
June 19, 2005 5:57 AM
 

Ian Smith said:

Just in case you missed it Rory, the BBC announced earlier this week that they'd not only signed for a second series, but now a third series too - in the UK at least. It seems that so many people are tuning in the BBC recognise that they actually have a major British hit on their hands.

Each season is only 13 episodes (with a Christmas special added in each year too).

And Russell T has confirmed the cybermen will be appearing in the second series.

Life is good!
June 19, 2005 7:39 AM
 

Rory said:

Ian -

"Life is good!"

Life is... *mostly* good.

I just finished the last episode. Here's what I think:

1) Rose just completely kicked so much ass that I feel like a little bit of my own ass somehow got kicked in the process - wonderful
2) This was, perhaps, the best Doctor Who episode I've ever seen
3) I'm going to miss the hell out of Christopher Eccleston

If it weren't for item #3, I'd be quite happy.

But, better the new guy than no guy :)

It reminds me of how Patrick McGoohan decided to leave Secret Agent at its height of popularity - he didn't want to stick around until it was old and tired.

Although Eccleston's reasons for leaving are different, the result is the same - he'll be remembered for the few things he did well instead of diluting that concentrated mass of goodness with years and years and years of mediocrity.

(Note that this is just what I'm telling myself to make all of this easier to deal with.)
June 19, 2005 8:03 AM
 

Earl said:

This is the only place I can find a hint of the 2nd series airing in the US, especially first-run episodes. Is there any info on time, network, etc? Is there a link? I would love to see Doctor Who here in the states.
June 19, 2005 10:52 PM
 

GuyIncognito said:

I thought Captain Jack was a decent sidekick. He's sort of a flesh and bone K9 to Rose's Leela.

I sure am going to miss Doctor number 9 though. :( He's hilarious and really picked up where Tom Baker left off. He sort of looks like Baker with a crew cut, now that I think of it.

I just picked up some great Doctor Who t-shirts at http://www.chunk.uk.com/trolleyed/172/173/168/index.htm

They're pretty expensive ($50 bucks for a t-shirt?!?!), but they're the best looking/quality doctor who t-shirts that I've been able to find. Man I can't wait until they invent virtual shoplifting...

My favorite episodes of the new Doctor Who had to be #3 "the unquiet dead" and #10 "the doctor dances".

"Don't drop the banana!"
"Why not?"
"It's a good source of potassium!"


Banter like that just makes me giggle like a school girl... :)


I don't watch many television shows (there just isn't that much that's good on these days), but if I do, it's always off tivo or a torrent. I hate watching commericals... so sue me... (not a real invitation).
June 20, 2005 3:27 AM
 

GuyIncognito said:

btw, i heard a rumor that rose is also leaving during the second season.

June 20, 2005 3:37 AM
 

Belle said:

I'm from Australia, and we have to usually wait AGES for our TV networks to show new episodes of shows... And it's hard to go look at sites when you risk the chance of being 'spoiled' when the eps aren't going to air for another 4 months or something like that here! Really frustrating :) I think about 90% of my friends don't even watch 'tv' anymore, it's all about the bittorrent!!
June 20, 2005 5:30 AM
 

Rory said:

GuyIncognito -

"I thought Captain Jack was a decent sidekick. He's sort of a flesh and bone K9 to Rose's Leela."

I don't know... I miss K9, and I wouldn't compare the two.

I liked him, but he was easily the worst actor of the bunch, although his stilted, overacted bit might have been to make his 'merican accent understandable to the Britlets in the audience. Kids might have a tough time with 'merican accents.

"I sure am going to miss Doctor number 9 though. :( He's hilarious and really picked up where Tom Baker left off. He sort of looks like Baker with a crew cut, now that I think of it."

I hadn't thought about it, but you're right about the hair.

I'm tempted to compare him to Tom Baker and to choose him as my new Favorite Doctor, but the comparison just isn't right. They both kicked ass in their own ways.

That said, Christopher was... yeah. Pretty damned good.

"My favorite episodes of the new Doctor Who had to be #3 'the unquiet dead' and #10 'the doctor dances'."

I loved "The Doctor Dances" - the ending was charming. It gets my seal of approval.

My favorite episode, outside the last one anyway, was probably "Dalek". I know it seems like the cheap and easy one to like, but I love it when people take the familiar and make it fresh. Before "Dalek" the Daleks were just props in force. After "Dalek" they had a little bit of depth. The Doctor did, too - I love the "You would make a good Dalek" line. Well done.

"btw, i heard a rumor that rose is also leaving during the second season."

Good. I think of her as Eccleston's Who Girl - not the new guy who looks like an emaciated Martin Short in high-heels.
June 20, 2005 6:21 AM
 

Martin said:

BBC America aren't really much to do with the BBC in the UK - they rely on advertising to sustain their output, and not all programmes shown on the BBCA network are derived from BBC UK content.

Neither are they a dumping ground for BBC archive content - they still have to purchase rights to BBC programmes like any other non-UK broadcaster.
June 20, 2005 11:17 AM
 

Jason said:

I had always spent saturday nights watching Baker, Davison, Baker, McCoy reruns on NJN (public tv -- the ones that licenced the franchise locally), and have continued the tradition by downloading the eps of the net...perfect HDTV mpeg2 caps, great for dvd's (after a lengthy conversion to NTSC instead of the native PAL using NeroVision Express) However I'm justifying it by buying the dvd's off of amazon... uk... (the us site doesn't have it :( )... looks like 3 eps per dvd set

Volume 1: 9.99 pounds
http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/ASIN/B00095L9E2/qid=1119279015/sr=8-2/ref=sr_8_xs_ap_i2_xgl/202-8416839-5221464

Volume 2: 9.99 pounds
http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/ASIN/B00095L9EC/qid=1119279015/sr=8-1/ref=sr_8_xs_ap_i1_xgl/202-8416839-5221464
June 20, 2005 2:52 PM
 

Tim Ensor said:

Rose will be leaving some time in season two - there was as story on it on the bbc website a few weeks ago.

Ahhh Billy Piper. She took all the TARDIS could give. Ahem.

I'm looking forward to David Tennant. In the States you wont have seen him I imagine but he's done a couple of things for the BBC - best of which was Cassanova. You might want to look for that on BT if you want to get a flavour of what kind of actor he is - its an excellent series! Actually I hope he plays the Doctor the same way...
June 20, 2005 4:22 PM
 

Paul Murphy said:

June 21, 2005 5:16 PM
 

David said:

As a long term Doctor Who fan, the thought of not being able to see the 2nd and 3rd series until they arrive on DVD, when I relocate to the US in the near future is one of the few downsides of the move (The other is that beer never seems to be correctly in the US, just below or at room temperature.)
June 22, 2005 9:09 AM
 

Chris said:

The idea to just distribute a bittorrent version with commercials and all that jazz is really no better than just letting pirated versions out. People will not watch the commercials and will definately not go out and click nag links.. Not to mention that there are people out there who would just chop all the extraneous stuff and then redistrubute that...

The only solution that I can think of that has a chance is a subscription based model with DRM protected media. But then you lose the bittorent angle and the company would have to support the bandwidth themselves
June 27, 2005 9:46 PM
New Comments to this post are disabled

About Rory

I *own* this site, you loser.